2287 W. 5th St., Washington, NC 27889 (252) 946-0920
Tue-Fri 8am-5:30pm · Sat 8am-2pm EST Map & Hours
AVALANCHE MOTORSPORTS
Your #1 Powersport & Marine Store
(252) 946-0920
Home›Sea Fox Boats›Bay Fox Series›251 Bay Fox vs. Robalo 246 Cayman
AM
Brian Zimmerman
Sea Fox Sales Specialist & Boat Expert · Avalanche Motorsports, Washington NC
15+ years selling Sea Fox boats in Eastern NC · #1 Sea Fox Dealer USA ·
✓ Verified Dealer Review
Sea Fox vs. Robalo  ·  Honest Comparison

Sea Fox 251 Bay Fox vs. Robalo 246 Cayman

This page compares the Sea Fox 251 Bay Fox and Robalo 246 Cayman side by side — specs, price, fuel range, livewell, hull design, and warranty — written by Avalanche Motorsports, the #1 Sea Fox dealer in North Carolina. Both boats are available for sea trial in Washington, NC.

Sea Fox 251 Bay Fox (~$70,000) vs. Robalo 246 Cayman (~$100,795) — Sea Fox costs $46,000 less and is 1,538 lbs lighter (3,362 vs 4,900 lbs). Robalo supports 350 HP (vs 300 HP), carries more fuel (90 vs 72 gal), and is rated for 10 persons vs 8. Sea Fox ships with a 36-gallon livewell and a Lifetime Structural Hull Warranty. Honest comparison from Avalanche Motorsports, the #1 Sea Fox dealer in the USA.

Quick Answer —Sea Fox 251 Bay Fox costs $46,000 less and is 1,538 lbs lighter than the Robalo 246 Cayman. Sea Fox wins on price, weight, and livewell (36 gal). Robalo wins on HP ceiling (350 vs 300), fuel (90 vs 72 gal), beam (9'0" vs 8'6"), and 10-person capacity. Walk both at Avalanche Motorsports in Washington, NC.

(252) 946-0920 Ask a Question
sea-fox-251-bay-fox ° inventory photo 1
1 / 18
~$70,000 MSRP*Estimated MSRP
Robalo
246 Cayman
robalo-246-cayman ° inventory photo 1
1 / 16
~$116,000 MSRP*Estimated MSRP

251 Bay Fox at a Glance

24Length
8Beam
8Capacity
72 galFuel Tank
300 HPMax Power
15°Deadrise
14"Draft
3,362 lbsDry Weight
~$680/moEst. Payment
POWER OPTIONS
  • VF250XB SHO
  • F300XSB2
BOW
  • Stainless steel bow eye with chafe plate
  • Anchor compartment with rope storage locker
  • Trolling motor outlet & harness (12/24/36 volt)
  • LED navigation lights
  • LED livewell light
  • Large casting deck
  • Insulated bow storage boxes
  • Rod storage lockers (Port and Starboard)
  • In-floor storage with 5-gallon bucket
  • Forward console seating with contoured backrest
  • Console livewell (10) gallons, 800 GPH aerator
  • Livewell lid window
HELM
  • Dometic SeaStar hydraulic steering system with tilt helm
  • Two digital gauges with backlighting. Tachometer and speedometer with volt, fuel, and push button functions
  • For Yamaha digital motors (Multifunction instrumentation with tachometer, speedometer, volt, fuel, and fuel management functions. Display may vary with availability. Helm will vary with engine choice.)
  • Acrylic Dash
  • Wet Sounds Marine Stereo
  • Six Wet Sounds marine speakers in deck
  • Windscreen
  • Top mount compass on console
  • Console dash shroud
  • Dash space for flush electronics (compatible for two 12" displays)
  • Stainless steel steering wheel with turning knob
  • Lockable console door
  • Console handrails
  • Integrated console footrest
  • 12-volt power point
  • Battery switch
  • Console courtesy lights
  • Pre-rigging for two batteries
  • Marine grade soft mat decking and console accents
  • Easy access battery compartment (holds up to six batteries)
COCKPIT
  • Leaning post helm seating with backrest and hinged bolsters
  • Stainless steel compression latches
  • Cup holders (6)
  • Stainless steel rod holders (4)
  • Aft bench seat with easy access hinged cushions
  • Self bailing cockpit with stainless steel grates
  • Transom livewell (26) gallons, 800 GPH aerator
  • Livewell light
TRANSOM
  • Transom storage compartments - plumbed and insulated for use as a cooler
  • Raw water washdown with splashwell outlet
  • Bulkhead fittings for hydraulic hoses in splashwell
  • Stainless steel transom saver
  • Stainless steel rear boarding telescopic ladders with integrated hull platforms
  • Stainless steel through bolted grab rail
  • Electric trim tabs
  • Stainless steel U-bolts on port and starboard transom
BILGE
  • Marine fuel/water separating filter
  • 1100 GPH bilge pumps with built in electronic float switches (2)
  • Raw water pump
  • Composite hull & deck
  • Isothalic gelcoat
  • Vinyl ester barrier coat
  • Sand-grip deck surface
  • Stainless steel rub rail
  • Stainless steel fasteners
  • Stainless steel through hulls
  • Stainless steel pull-up cleats (7)
  • Limited Lifetime Hull Warranty
PowerYamaha 300 HPF150 · F200 · F225 · F250 (max)
View 251 Bay Fox Full Details →View 251 Bay Fox Inventory →
251 Bay Fox Details on SeaFoxBoats.com →
2027 Model YearSea Fox

New Standard

  • ★Standard Wet Sounds stereo system — Wet Sounds stereo system now included as standard equipment on all models 26 feet and under.
251 Bay Fox — Why Avalanche Buyers Choose It
  • ✓Lifetime structural hull warranty
    Key West offers 10 years — Sea Fox is lifetime
  • ✓#1 Sea Fox dealer in the USA
    Hands-on support from Washington, NC
  • ✓Carolina Flare hull engineering
    Built for NC coastal conditions
  • ✓Strong resale value
    Sea Fox holds value well in the used market
View 251 Bay Fox Inventory →Get a Quote
Speak With a Sea Fox Expert (252) 946-0920 - OR - Ask a Question

246 Cayman at a Glance

24'6"Length
9'Beam
9Capacity
90 galFuel Tank
350 HPMax Power
16°Deadrise
16"Draft
4,900 lbsDry Weight
~$828/moEst. Payment
POWER
  • Stainless Steel Prop
TOPS
  • Fiberglass Hardtop w/ Powder Coated Frame (Black or White) — Bonded Windshield, 4 Rod Holders, Storage Box, LED Spreader Lights, Integrated Console Grab Rails
  • Shipping Cover
ELECTRICAL
  • 12V Wiring Buss Inside Console
  • Aluminum Panel w/ Weatherproof Stainless Steel Switches & Circuit Breakers
  • Bilge Pump with Automatic Switch
  • Custom Molded and Wrapped Helm Visor
  • Digital Engine Display
  • Dual Battery System with Crossover Switch and Voltage Sensing Relay (VSR)
  • Dual Pro USB / Power Plug
  • Electric Horn
  • Electrical Connectors Triple O-Ring Sealed and Water Tight
  • LED Navigation Lights
  • Lighted Compass
  • Owner's Dry Bag
  • SeaStar Tilt Hydraulic Steering
  • Stainless LED Electronic Push Button Switches and Water Resistant DC Breakers
  • Stainless Steel Steering Wheel with Control Knob
  • Stereo System — AM/FM Radio with Bluetooth and Water Resistant Speakers (4) with Blue LED Lighting
  • Tinned Copper Wiring with Waterproof Connectors
  • Waterproof Wireless Charging Dock
  • Wiring for Bow Trolling Motor
CONSOLE
  • Access Into Console from Forward Side with Step
  • Custom Bonded Front Windshield Glass with Open Vent Section Across Top
  • Forward Console Seat and Bolster
  • Head Pan with Non-Skid Surfaces
  • Integrated Dual Level Footrest
  • Lockable Glove Box
  • RTM Fiberglass Console Door — Friction Hinged and Lockable
  • Stainless Steel Drink Holders (2)
COCKPIT
  • Aft Double-Wide Seat with Folding Backrests — Converts to Casting Platform
  • Bow Center Insulated Livewell (20 gal) — Dedicated Pump, LED Lighting, Blue Gelcoat, Adjustable Flow Valve
  • Bow Cushions (Removable)
  • Bow Rider U-Shaped Seating with Bolsters and Rod Storage Underneath
  • Bucket Storage under Aft Fiberglass Lid
  • Cockpit and Bow Coaming Bolsters
  • Cockpit LED Courtesy Lights — Blue
  • Diamond Lustre Non-Skid Surfaces
  • Forward Port Storage with Drain — Custom Molded, Easy Rod Storage
  • Forward Starboard Fish Box — Insulated (45 gal)
  • Horizontal Rod Storage under Gunwale (Port & Starboard)
  • Leaning Post w/ Dual Flip-Up Bolsters, Backrest, Rod Holders (4), and 50L Cooler (White or Black Powdercoated)
  • Molded Gunnel Inserts
  • Oversized Battery and Pump Compartment in Transom
  • Premium Stain Resistant Silicone Cockpit Fabric
  • Removable Bow Seating Backrests (Port and Starboard)
  • RTM Fiberglass Lids
  • Self Bailing Cockpit with Integrated Drain Fittings
  • Stainless Steel Cockpit Grab Rails
  • Stainless Steel Drink Holders (6)
  • Stainless Steel Friction Hinges on Molded Hatches
  • Stainless Steel Rod Holders Mounted in the Deck Gunwale (4)
  • Twin Aft Insulated Livewell/Fish Boxes (30 gal) — Dedicated Pumps, LED Lighting, Blue Gelcoat, Adjustable Flow Valves, Plexiglass Divider
CONSTRUCTION
  • Anchor Rope and Chain Locker at Bow
  • Brass High Speed Livewell Through Hull
  • Custom Molded Transom Trim
  • Dive Swim Platform (Starboard) with Three Step Boarding Ladder and Handle
  • Encapsulated Reserve Flotation
  • Fiberglass Structural System
  • Fuel/Water Separator
  • Garboard Drain
  • Heavy Duty Rubrail with Stainless Steel Insert
  • Hydro Lift™ Multi Angle Hull Design
  • Kevlar Reinforced Hull
  • Limited Lifetime Hull Warranty
  • NMMA Certified using ABYC Standards
  • Poured Composite Transom Coring
  • Raw Water Washdown System
  • Stainless Steel Bow Eye Chafe Plate
  • Stainless Steel Pull-Up Cleats (6)
  • Stainless Steel Stern Eyes
  • Stainless Steel Thru Hull Fittings
TRAILER
  • Aluminum Tandem Axle Trailer — Disc Brakes (4 wheels), 14" Galvanized Wheels, LED Submersible Lights, Winch Stand w/ Safety Straps, Trailer Side Guides
PowerYamaha 350 HP max

The Verdict

Sea Fox 251 Bay Fox costs $46,000 less and is 1,538 lbs lighter than the Robalo 246 Cayman — real advantages for NC inshore bay fishing where weight and ramp ease matter. Sea Fox also ships with a 36-gallon livewell and a Lifetime Structural Hull Warranty. Robalo 246 Cayman earns its premium with 350 HP headroom, 90 gallons of fuel, a wider 9-foot beam, and 10-person capacity. For most NC inshore anglers who fish with 2–4 people and want a lighter, more maneuverable bay boat with a quality livewell, Sea Fox 251 Bay Fox wins. For buyers who want maximum power headroom, wider cockpit, and more fuel range, Robalo 246 Cayman is worth the extra cost.

Key Takeaways

Sea Fox costs $46,000 lessSea Fox Wins

~$70,000 vs. ~$116,000. Sea Fox is both lighter and cheaper — a rare combination.

Sea Fox is 1,538 lbs lighter — huge inshore advantageSea Fox Wins

3,362 lbs vs 4,900 lbs. Sea Fox planes faster, solo-launches easier, and is more fuel efficient.

Sea Fox ships with a 36-gallon livewellSea Fox Wins

Published standard spec. Robalo does not publish livewell capacity. For live bait fishing, Sea Fox is the documented winner.

Robalo supports 350 HP — Sea Fox maxes at 300 HPRobalo Wins

Robalo 246 Cayman can run a Yamaha F350. Sea Fox 251 Bay Fox caps at 300 HP. For maximum power headroom, Robalo wins.

Robalo carries 90 gallons and seats 10Robalo Wins

18 more gallons of fuel and 2 more persons than Sea Fox. For longer trips with larger groups, Robalo has more capacity.

Why Buyers Cross-Shop These Boats

Two 24-foot single-engine bay boats at similar prices. The cross-shop comes down to what the $5,795 gap buys:

  • Price: Sea Fox 251 Bay Fox ~$70,000; Robalo 246 Cayman ~$100,795. Sea Fox costs $46,000 less.
  • Weight: Sea Fox 3,362 lbs vs Robalo 4,900 lbs. Sea Fox is 1,538 lbs lighter — massive inshore advantage.
  • Livewell: Sea Fox ships with a 36-gallon livewell. Robalo lists a livewell but does not publish capacity.
  • Power: Robalo supports 350 HP (vs Sea Fox 300 HP). If you want a Yamaha F300, only Robalo supports it fully.
  • Fuel: Robalo carries 90 gallons; Sea Fox 72 gallons. Robalo has 18 more gallons of range.
  • Beam: Robalo 9'0" vs Sea Fox 8'6". Robalo has more cockpit width.
  • Warranty: Sea Fox Lifetime Structural Hull + 5-yr blister, transferable. Robalo limited structural warranty.

Come to Avalanche Motorsports in Washington, NC and walk both before you decide.

Sea Fox vs. Robalo: Price and Value

As the #1 Sea Fox dealer in the USA, we have this conversation every week. Here is what the numbers show.

Robalo · starts at ~$116,000

246 Cayman

Starting at ~$116,000 depending on engine selection and options. A fully rigged, sea-ready 246 Cayman with electronics, outboards, and trailer will land most buyers above this figure.

Sea Fox · starts at ~$70,000

251 Bay Fox

Starting at ~$70,000 ° $46,000 less than the 246 Cayman at ~$116,000. Even rigged comparably, Sea Fox delivers more for less here.

Why Sea Fox Wins

The monthly payment difference is roughly $148/mo ° Sea Fox costs less here. Here is what you give up at the lower price point:

  • 18 more gallons (90 vs 72) on the 246 Cayman
  • Warranty: Lifetime structural hull on Sea Fox vs Limited lifetime hull on Robalo
  • Livewell: Sea Fox ships with a 36 gal total (vs 20-gal bow center livewell + 30-gal twin aft livewell/fishboxes on Robalo)

Run the Numbers Yourself

Adjust the prices, down payment, rate, and term to see what the gap actually costs you every month.

251BF-
Robalo 246 Cayman-
Monthly Difference-
Total Difference Over 20 years-

Estimates for comparison only, before tax, title, registration, and fees. Not a financing offer or quote - rates and terms depend on credit approval. Call (252) 946-0920 for current offers.

Build Quality: Sea Fox vs. Robalo

Both the Sea Fox 251 Bay Fox and Robalo 246 Cayman are all-composite center consoles built for saltwater use. Build quality is comparable — the differences are in warranty depth, hull geometry, and spec priorities.

Both all-compositeZero woodSF: Lifetime hull warranty
Robalo

Full fiberglass structural system, Kevlar reinforced hull, poured composite transom coring, Hydro Lift™ multi-angle hull design Construction

Robalo boats are manufactured by Chaparral Boats at the company facility in Nashville, Georgia. The brand construction approach centers on open-mold, hand-laid fiberglass for both hull and deck assemblies. Robalo public quality page confirms hand-lay-up as the primary build method but does not publish specific resin type, stringer system material, or transom core composition.

Robalo occupies the value-to-mid-range fiberglass center console segment and produces a wide range of models from small bay boats to larger offshore center consoles. Construction detail transparency is limited compared to brands that publish full laminate specifications; gelcoat type, barrier coat application, and stringer system naming are not disclosed on the brand website.

Robalo warranty terms, including structural coverage duration and transferability, are not publicly posted on robalo.com. Buyers seeking full warranty documentation should request it directly from an authorized Robalo dealer at the time of purchase.

Sea Fox

How Sea Fox Builds the 251 Bay Fox Hull

Sea Fox builds the 251 Bay Fox at their 200,000 sq ft factory in Moncks Corner, South Carolina. The hull is designed by a naval architect and the plug is CNC cut on a five-axis router before molds are pulled. Construction from the outside in:

  • Isothalic gelcoat — outer skin. Denser molecular structure than standard orthophthalic gelcoat; superior UV degradation resistance and osmotic blister resistance.
  • Vinyl ester barrier coat — low water absorption rate, the technical reason the 5-year blister warranty exists.
  • Hand-laid 36/10 oz fiberglass knit — 36-oz woven + 10-oz mat, hand rolled layer by layer into the mold.
  • 1708 fiberglass knit — used specifically in deck radius areas for strength and minimal flex at high-stress joints.
  • No Wood, No Rot all-composite construction foam-filled stringers — custom CAD-designed per model, closed-cell foam core, bonded directly to cockpit sole. Closed-cell = sealed system; adds positive flotation even if gelcoat is breached.
  • Penske foam-core transom with glassed-in aluminum motor plate — zero wood; aluminum plate spreads engine load across the full transom width.
  • High-density foam-cored deck — chemically bonded hull-to-deck joint; no mechanical fasteners = no leak path at the seam.
  • Closed-cell foam flotation throughout — meets and exceeds USCG Level Flotation requirements.

Warranty: Limited Lifetime Structural (original owner) → 10-year transferable (second owner) → 5-year blister (prorated) → 3-year deck hardware → 2-year electrical/plumbing. At 10+ years in saltwater service, properly maintained Sea Fox hulls show excellent gelcoat retention and structural integrity.

Are Sea Fox Boats Reliable? How Long Do Sea Fox Boats Last? What Size Truck to Tow a Sea Fox?

Side-by-Side Specs: 251 Bay Fox vs. 246 Cayman

→ Swipe table to see full comparison

SpecSea Fox 251 Bay FoxRobalo 246 Cayman
LOA2424'6"
Beam89'
Deadrise15°16°
Fuel Capacity72 gal90 gal
Max HP300 HP350 HP
Draft14"16"
Dry Weight3,362 lbs4,900 lbs
Person Capacity89
Livewell36 gal total20-gal bow center livewell + 30-gal twin aft livewell/fishboxes
Hull WarrantyLifetime structural hullLimited lifetime hull
MSRP (Starting)$70,000$115,695
Price Difference~$46,000 less than Robalo 246 Cayman—
Monthly Payment (~240 mo)~$680/mo~$828/mo
Interested in a Sea Fox? Get a Quote on the Sea Fox 251 Bay Fox

Speak directly with the #1 Sea Fox dealer in the USA — Washington, NC

Call (252) 946-0920

Ready to See It In Person?

21 Sea Fox 228 Commanders In Stock — Washington, NC

We're the #1 Sea Fox dealer in the USA. Schedule a sea trial on Pamlico Sound — same week, no pressure.

(252) 946-0920 — Call Now View 228 Commander Inventory

Who Should Buy Sea Fox vs. Robalo: Match the Right Boat to Your Needs

The Value Case — from ~$95,000

Choose 251BF if…

  • 18° Carolina Flare deep-V hull — outward bow flare for a dry, controlled ride in Pamlico Sound chop and Eastern NC coastal conditions
  • You want vinyl ester + isothalic construction with zero wood for long-term saltwater durability
  • You want dealer support from the #1 Sea Fox dealer in the USA — Washington, NC
  • A ~300 HP max rating is adequate for your 25-foot bay boat use
  • ~72 gallons of fuel meets your range needs for Eastern NC inshore and nearshore fishing
  • You fish Eastern NC waters (Pamlico Sound, Albemarle Sound, the Outer Banks flats)
  • You want factory-certified service on-site at Avalanche Motorsports
The Prestige Case

Choose Robalo if…

  • You want the higher 350 HP max rating for maximum engine performance in the 25-foot class
  • You have a Robalo dealer locally with strong service support
  • You are primarily inshore and a 25'3" LOA with 68-gallon fuel works for your fishing
  • You value Robalo's Columbia, SC manufacturing heritage and bay boat track record
  • You can find a competitive price on the Robalo R246 Cayman in your market
  • Prior Robalo ownership experience or brand loyalty drives your preference

Everything Buyers Ask: Frequently Asked Questions

Select a category below to view common questions and our honest answers.

Category 01

Price & Value

The price gap, and who each boat is honestly right for.

At $0 down, 240 months, 5.99% APR: Sea Fox 251 Bay Fox is approximately $680/mo; Robalo 246 Cayman is approximately $722/mo. About $42/mo more for the Robalo. On approved credit.

The Price Gap at a Glance
$6,000+
More for the Robalo 246 Cayman

What You Get With Sea Fox for Less

Offshore Capability

15° Carolina Flare hull, 72-gal fuel, built for the waters Carolina buyers actually fish.

Built to Last

All-composite construction with a Limited Lifetime Hull Warranty. Zero wood. Ever.

Strong Equipment

36 gal total, In-floor fish boxes, 9 rod holders — standard.

Comparable ROI

Net depreciation per year is roughly equal — at a far lower entry price.

$6,000+Upfront savings
$36,000Saved over the life of a 240-mo. loan
~$680/moEst. payment, 251 Bay Fox — $0 down, 5.99% APR, 240 mo.
~$828/moEst. payment, 246 Cayman — $0 down, 5.99% APR, 240 mo.
Still have a question? Call our Sea Fox experts at (252) 946-0920
#1 Sea Fox Dealer in the USA
Factory PricingManufacturer relationships = real deals
Certified ServiceSea Fox & Yamaha factory-trained
15+ Years NC WatersOregon Inlet to Pamlico Sound
Our Take

Sea Fox 251 Bay Fox: Built for NC Waters

Sea Fox 251 Bay Fox — built in Moncks Corner, SC with a lifetime structural warranty, vinylester barrier coat, and No Wood, No Rot all-composite construction stringers. Priced from $116,000 at Avalanche Motorsports.

We sell Sea Fox. We don't sell Robalo. Factor that in — and read anyway, because we're going to be straight with you.

Robalo 246 Cayman — a capable boat from Robalo, priced from $115,695. Solid choice if you prefer their dealer network, but Sea Fox wins on build transparency, warranty transferability, and delivered value at Avalanche.

Open Tue–Fri 8am–5:30pm · Sat 8am–2pm EST · Sea Fox boats in NC

Quote Request · No Pressure

Interested in a Sea Fox? Get a Quote on the Sea Fox 251 Bay Fox

Or call (252) 946-0920 · We never share your information.

Explore More Sea Fox Resources

Helpful guides, comparisons, and model information to help you make the right decision.

Other Sea Fox Models to Consider

View All Sea Fox Models →
Visit Avalanche Motorsports

2287 W. 5th St., Washington, NC 27889
Tue-Fri 8am-5:30pm · Sat 8am-2pm EST

Get Directions →

#1 Sea Fox Dealer in the USA
  • Largest Selection
  • Fast Delivery
  • Factory Certified
  • Parts & Service
  • Expert Support
  • Family Owned
Questions? We're Here to Help (252) 946-0920 Contact Our Team
Written & Reviewed By

Avalanche Motorsports - Washington, NC - #1 Sea Fox Dealer USA

We're a 20+ year old dealership serving boaters across Eastern NC and beyond. Our team lives and breathes boating and we're here to help you find the perfect Sea Fox for your adventures.

20+ YearsIn Business
ThousandsHappy Customers
6,000+Boats Delivered
Call (252) 946-0920 Chat Now

ⓘ Pricing estimates as of October 2026. Sea Fox 251 Bay Fox: ~$70,000++ based on current Avalanche Motorsports inventory. Robalo 246 Cayman: ~$116,000+ based on published dealer prices. Excludes tax, title, registration, and fees.